导演: Alexis Durand-Brault
主演: Christian Bégin / Karine Vanasse
主演: Christian Bégin / Karine Vanasse
上映年度: 2007年2月16日 加拿大
语言: 法语
制片国家/地区: 加拿大
语言: 法语
制片国家/地区: 加拿大
imdb链接: tt0456521
X
登录 · · · · · ·
剧情简介 · · · · · ·
黑色恐怖故事《Ma fille, mon ange》的公映将成为2月16日开幕的“魁北克电影节Rendez-vous du cinema quebecois”的开场作。深受魁北克观众欢迎的悲剧演员Michel Cote和 Karine Vanasse在影片中分别扮演了父亲和女儿。影片中,父亲发现女儿在互联网上的色情节目中出演角色引发了冲突。
Watched this on the satellite movie channel, and found, in the end, that it was fairly slight but entertaining. More so than many other movies, I found myself going through stages of like and dislike as My Fille, Mon Ange played out. My most serious condemnation, I think, is that I never completely got out of the mode of knowing that I was watching a movie (and the accompanying feeling of...how are they trying to manipulate me), as opposed to simply getting engrossed in the story.
My single largest 'like', I think, was more 'relief' than like: the storyline and the start of the movie had me wondering if these was going to be an unsubtle morality tale depicting the, gasp, horrors of pornography and pornographers. That's not a good thing, because I like both my heroes and my villains, even pornographers, to be a whole lot more rounded than that.
By the end, though, this was clearly a depiction of one family's response to an evolving situation, and it's pretty clear than there's not a lot of ground higher than the rest. Almost every character is depicted as conflicted or ambiguous in some way. Mr. Dagenais reacts viscerally to the prospect of his daughter having exhibitionistic sex, notwithstanding that he finds out about this while surfing porn sites while his wife waits in bed for him. The porn producer has a business to run, but in the end, gives Nathalie the opportunity to opt out...which she declines. Nathalie is going wild in Montreal, but we also see her writing an exam the morning of her shoot. She also clearly smiles at herself, looking into a mirror while having sex. Angelique criticizes Nathalie for contemplating doing a web porn shoot, but is a druggie stripper.
So, then, I'd argue that the theme is 'over-reaction', and the resulting risks.
The story was interesting enough, and I thought the performances were, on the whole, quite good.
The things I didn't like, and there were a few: - the non-linear story track didn't seem to be that effective or well-handled to me... - some of the dialog, and some of the acting, seemed a trifle clichéd and overwrought; some of that may have been 'lost in translation while on the way to the subtitles' effect, but I'm not sure... - I found the 'as subtle as a 2-by-4' observations about the decline of the church to be ineffectively heavy-handed.
One plot aspect that got in the way of my enjoyment is the concept of the enforceability of Nathalie's contract to 'perform'... I am definitely not an expert, but I don't think that any contract for sexual services is enforceable--and if the issue were 'pressed', I'm confident that criminal law regarding assault and sexual assault would trump the civil contract. And if Nathalie did break the civil contract, the pornographer's recourse would be limited to the losses incurred, which he would have to prove. So, I thought this was an extraneous plot element that really didn't add anything beyond table thumping opportunities.
My last comment, in passing: the keywords for this movie include anal sex and painful sex. While I can see where one might have inferred same should one be inclined to rush to that inference, I'd argue that the scenes are much too brief, much too ambiguous to conclude that either occurred
Watched this on the satellite movie channel, and found, in the end, that it was fairly slight but entertaining. More so than many other movies, I found myself going through stages of like and dislike as My Fille, Mon Ange played out. My most serious condemnation, I think, is that I never completely got out of the mode of knowing that I was watching a movie (and the accompanying feeling of...how are they trying to manipulate me), as opposed to simply getting engrossed in the story.
My single largest 'like', I think, was more 'relief' than like: the storyline and the start of the movie had me wondering if these was going to be an unsubtle morality tale depicting the, gasp, horrors of pornography and pornographers. That's not a good thing, because I like both my heroes and my villains, even pornographers, to be a whole lot more rounded than that.
By the end, though, this was clearly a depiction of one family's response to an evolving situation, and it's pretty clear than there's not a lot of ground higher than the rest. Almost every character is depicted as conflicted or ambiguous in some way. Mr. Dagenais reacts viscerally to the prospect of his daughter having exhibitionistic sex, notwithstanding that he finds out about this while surfing porn sites while his wife waits in bed for him. The porn producer has a business to run, but in the end, gives Nathalie the opportunity to opt out...which she declines. Nathalie is going wild in Montreal, but we also see her writing an exam the morning of her shoot. She also clearly smiles at herself, looking into a mirror while having sex. Angelique criticizes Nathalie for contemplating doing a web porn shoot, but is a druggie stripper.
So, then, I'd argue that the theme is 'over-reaction', and the resulting risks.
The story was interesting enough, and I thought the performances were, on the whole, quite good.
The things I didn't like, and there were a few: - the non-linear story track didn't seem to be that effective or well-handled to me... - some of the dialog, and some of the acting, seemed a trifle clichéd and overwrought; some of that may have been 'lost in translation while on the way to the subtitles' effect, but I'm not sure... - I found the 'as subtle as a 2-by-4' observations about the decline of the church to be ineffectively heavy-handed.
One plot aspect that got in the way of my enjoyment is the concept of the enforceability of Nathalie's contract to 'perform'... I am definitely not an expert, but I don't think that any contract for sexual services is enforceable--and if the issue were 'pressed', I'm confident that criminal law regarding assault and sexual assault would trump the civil contract. And if Nathalie did break the civil contract, the pornographer's recourse would be limited to the losses incurred, which he would have to prove. So, I thought this was an extraneous plot element that really didn't add anything beyond table thumping opportunities.
My last comment, in passing: the keywords for this movie include anal sex and painful sex. While I can see where one might have inferred same should one be inclined to rush to that inference, I'd argue that the scenes are much too brief, much too ambiguous to conclude that either occurred
豆瓣成员常用的标签(共90个) · · · · · ·
"Ma fille, mon ange"论坛 · · · · · ·
| 那个爸爸还演过什么啊? | 来自阿随|海带,海带 | 2008-11-07 | |
| 道德沦丧的世界 | 来自娱乐广告™月薪2000活在北京 | 2 回应 | 2008-11-07 |
| 我想看,谁有下载资源,共享一下。 | 来自宀,暖年 | 4 回应 | 2008-10-03 |
| 简单说下 | 来自左胸上的吸盘(侬本纯良) | 2008-08-17 | |
| 下载(Namipan) | 来自NIN | 2008-08-12 |
> 浏览更多话题
X
登录 · · · · · ·
豆瓣成员最受欢迎的影评 (9条) · · · · · ·
你的女儿我的情儿
-
- 胡子‖大家都是中出下的产物(西安) 文/胡子 变态爸爸在看少女性爱网上直播,人家还是这种网站的会员呢!看着看着,看见了自己年少美丽女儿风骚的对摄像头说5月19号我们网上见哦。变态的爸爸生气了,怎么世界上有这么肮脏的事情,我的女儿怎么可能操逼,只有你们的女儿才会操逼!变态的爸爸瞬时间变身了。 《Ma fille, mon ange》题材不错,挺...... (64回应)
2008-09-28 57/65人推荐
生活这条线上的一个大疙瘩
-
- 清凉薄荷吸入剂 又被电驴忽悠了,那位大婶这么牛呀,翻译成:边做边摄…… 对同音字比较敏感的我,一看这么牛B的名字加上海报,马上就浮想联翩了,哪位老兄怎么凶悍呀…… 看完了,完全不是那么一回事,但是,一点都不失望,很好看,真的。一部开始用快进,接着慢下来,然后又回过头仔细从头看起的影片。 不得不说,很棒了。 这位老爸,就是那......
2008-10-18
当噱头变成考验伦理的入口
-
- elily(烟台) 看了很多电影,总是会被中文译名误导。 就像这一部《Ma fille, mon ange》。起初一直以为是在德国拍摄的,演员们操的欧洲语言听着很费劲。但是,片子在我选择观看以后峰回路转的影响了我对一些问题的原有影像。 首先,青春期的叛逆,谁来承担不能承受之重? 女儿,如花似玉,父亲,如日中天。他们家......
2008-08-31
AV引起的血案:愤怒母亲力杀男优
-
- phoenie(北京) 一个受室友影响而堕落的女孩,自以为很隐秘地去拍AV,其实家里人都知道。父亲为此改行干了007的活儿,顺着线索一路追查,又是闯入民宅,又是假扮投资人,又是持枪打人;母亲更狠,在拍片前夕大闹片场,直接干掉了男主角,搞得警察北都找不着。看了本片,我的背后不禁一阵阵地冒凉气,这就是报应么?可怜地小女孩连肛交的滋味都没尝到就臭大...... (1回应)
2008-11-07
Ma fille,mon ange 关于青春 生活 我们 现在 未来 ...
-
- 木质的快乐 生命中一个一个幸福的剪影 父亲与女儿 渐渐的浮现而又远去 难得有的好的心境 把这个偶得的下午留给电影 是的 好好地去感受生活 Ma fille,mon ange 我的女孩 我的天使 摆满桌子的合影的幸福 女儿在化妆着打电话 即将离开父母身边 去生活 电话的另一边是另外......
2008-10-11
X
登录 · · · · · ·
二手碟交换 · · · · · ·
- 2008我最喜愛的電影評選既春天獎評選 (来自: 逝去的春天)
















