2009-07-03 18:06:32
来自: 旧精魂
(“俛而不答”)
Beethoven: String Quartet Op.130, Op.133的评论
A very ---for lack of a better word--- VIRILE rendition of the "Grosse Fuge". Some may find it too strident, especially those who like the honeyed tone of Quartetto Itliano among others. But to some, like myself, the playing highly enlightening. Highlights a Beethoven more modernist than in other interpretations.
Is there merit in such relish of dissonance? Probably not, when you listen to a "mainstream" performance of Op. 130, of which that the "Fugue" was originally intended as the final movement. Sure one can argue that's perhaps why Matthias Artaria advised Beethoven to compose a new one, but one would have expected greater continuity of style... nevertheless, Hagen offers a great trip to an exciting place; who cares if it may have been ahistorical?
Beethoven: String Quartet Op.130, Op.133的评论
A very ---for lack of a better word--- VIRILE rendition of the "Grosse Fuge". Some may find it too strident, especially those who like the honeyed tone of Quartetto Itliano among others. But to some, like myself, the playing highly enlightening. Highlights a Beethoven more modernist than in other interpretations.
Is there merit in such relish of dissonance? Probably not, when you listen to a "mainstream" performance of Op. 130, of which that the "Fugue" was originally intended as the final movement. Sure one can argue that's perhaps why Matthias Artaria advised Beethoven to compose a new one, but one would have expected greater continuity of style... nevertheless, Hagen offers a great trip to an exciting place; who cares if it may have been ahistorical?
本评论版权属于作者旧精魂，并受法律保护。除非评论正文中另有声明，没有作者本人的书面许可任何人不得转载或使用整体或任何部分的内容。
>Beethoven: String Quartet Op.130, Op.133
唱片数: 1
条型码: 0028947158028
发行时间: 2005-03-10
唱片名: Beethoven: String Quartet Op.130, Op.133
表演者: Hagen Quartett
版本特性: Import
出版者: Deutsche Grammophon
介质: Audio CD
> 我来回应