2008-05-11 03:25:30
来自: 人形影
He Was a Quiet Man / 曾经安静的男人的评论
提示: 有关键情节透露
没看懂，全连一块的话
imdb上看一篇comment说结局不是open-ended
然后这儿那儿又看了一些，没有特别圆满的解释，也懒得去想了
所以还是回到中间那一段“普通”的情节，只是Venessa和Bob那一段故事，不管其他。希望总是来的不是时候的，Venessa手指动那么一下的时候，意味着整个生死的状态就发生的转变，不得不重新考虑。而事实上可能每一次希望只是延长现有的痛苦。原来关于爱情的浪漫的表达，确实是不会穷尽的，那些细节，包括那一段非常风格化的光影流转，我很喜欢。
改天再看看，看会不会发现那些所谓的细节--以下转自imdb.com
t is simply unbelievable..., 22 January 2008
9/10
Author: ppmaker from Russian Federation
...that a human mind is capable of creating such intriguing plot - so terrifying and captivating this movie is. Frank Capello is obviously a man of genius. But he is not nice and gentle to his audience. The movie is sharp-straight, honest and pretty cruel to a person watching it. It doesn't compromise. Don't expect it to comply with general drama movie rules.
*** BE AWARE OF SPOILERS BELOW ***
After you ve seen 50% of it or so you think it's pretty common drama, quite predictable and possibly happily ending one. Well, its not. Not at all. And so shockingly not.
Cast is perfect. I would never think Slater could fit into the role of Bob. W.Macy would fit better, I thought. But these thoughts faded away.
The movie is not open-ended despite what some people say. You just have to think harder than you usually do while watching a regular movie. Be more attentive or watch it again.
Capello makes you think. If you want to know what really happened, (if anything happened at all) analyze the details. There are answers.
I give 9 out of 10, because Capello rudely and savagely ruined my hopes for the better ending :) In the most gruesome way possible.
He Was a Quiet Man / 曾经安静的男人的评论
提示: 有关键情节透露
没看懂，全连一块的话
imdb上看一篇comment说结局不是open-ended
然后这儿那儿又看了一些，没有特别圆满的解释，也懒得去想了
所以还是回到中间那一段“普通”的情节，只是Venessa和Bob那一段故事，不管其他。希望总是来的不是时候的，Venessa手指动那么一下的时候，意味着整个生死的状态就发生的转变，不得不重新考虑。而事实上可能每一次希望只是延长现有的痛苦。原来关于爱情的浪漫的表达，确实是不会穷尽的，那些细节，包括那一段非常风格化的光影流转，我很喜欢。
改天再看看，看会不会发现那些所谓的细节--以下转自imdb.com
t is simply unbelievable..., 22 January 2008
9/10
Author: ppmaker from Russian Federation
...that a human mind is capable of creating such intriguing plot - so terrifying and captivating this movie is. Frank Capello is obviously a man of genius. But he is not nice and gentle to his audience. The movie is sharp-straight, honest and pretty cruel to a person watching it. It doesn't compromise. Don't expect it to comply with general drama movie rules.
*** BE AWARE OF SPOILERS BELOW ***
After you ve seen 50% of it or so you think it's pretty common drama, quite predictable and possibly happily ending one. Well, its not. Not at all. And so shockingly not.
Cast is perfect. I would never think Slater could fit into the role of Bob. W.Macy would fit better, I thought. But these thoughts faded away.
The movie is not open-ended despite what some people say. You just have to think harder than you usually do while watching a regular movie. Be more attentive or watch it again.
Capello makes you think. If you want to know what really happened, (if anything happened at all) analyze the details. There are answers.
I give 9 out of 10, because Capello rudely and savagely ruined my hopes for the better ending :) In the most gruesome way possible.
本评论版权属于作者人形影，并受法律保护。除非评论正文中另有声明，没有作者本人的书面许可任何人不得转载或使用整体或任何部分的内容。
编剧: Frank A. Cappello
影名: He Was a Quiet Man
导演: Frank A. Cappello
简体中文名: 曾经安静的男人
制片国家/地区: 美国
上映日期: 2007-11-23
imdb编号: tt0760311
语言: 英语
主演: Christian Slater, Jamison Jones, William H. Macy, Cristina Lawson, Elisha Cuthbert
又名: 曾经安静的人, 安静的男人, 曾经安静的男人
> 我来回应